Renewable Energy Gaining Steam

What are the three main drivers of interest?

    Ketul Sakhpara, CFA

    Ketul Sakhpara, CFAPortfolio Manager/Research Analyst,Franklin Real Asset Advisors®

    Renewable energy has been gaining steam for many reasons, as have the investment opportunities in the space. Ketul Sakhpara, portfolio manager and research analyst, Franklin Real Asset Advisors, outlines the three main drivers of interest, and where his team sees potential. You might be surprised to learn how emerging markets in particular are ramping up renewable energy.

    Generating energy from renewable sources offers a number of benefits, including reducing our dependence on fossil fuels and diversifying our fuel sources. At the same time, it offers local governments a boost from associated property taxes which help fund schools, parks and emergency services like firefighters and police.

    Most renewable power plants are built after a fixed-price power purchase agreement (PPA) is signed for 10-20 years with a utility or a government-owned entity. Some PPAs also have inflation-linked revenue escalators. This eliminates most of the risk to the top line of the investment.

    Moreover, solar and wind power plants have very low operational and maintenance costs and zero fuel costs compared with conventional power plants such as coal, gas or nuclear. This can shield customers from unpredictable future power price increases and is a significant benefit for investors, since it eliminates the remaining major risk factors on returns from an investment in power plants. Hence, we think the renewables space is very well suited for infrastructure investors.

    There are many factors driving renewable investments, but we see three main ones.

    1. Decline of costs.
    2. Regulatory support in the form of tax credits and state-level mandates.
    3. Increasing awareness and push for sustainability.

    Each of these individual drivers is supportive, but when the effects of all three are combined, we think the impact is exponential. On the investment side, we rarely see such a confluence of factors. When the world’s largest economy is in the process of changing its source of fuel for power production, the potential opportunities are great in our view.

    Reduction in Costs

    The cost of generating power from wind and solar has declined 15-17% per year for the last 5-7 years.1 According to various estimates, the cost of producing power from wind and solar is expected to fall to 2 to 4 cents/kilowatt hour (kwh) in 2020, while gas, coal and nuclear will be 3 to 5 cents/kwh.2

    Solar and wind power is currently at parity or even cheaper in terms of cost in most parts of the United States when compared with conventional fuel sources such as gas, coal and nuclear power.

    US State Mandates

    States have been mandating expanding use of renewables, which is the second driver of growth. California currently produces about 30% of its consumed power from renewables, but has a mandate to produce 50% of its electricity from renewables by 2030.3 The state plans to be 100% carbon-free by 2045.

    New York has a similar mandate to reach 50% by 2030.4

    Overall, 29 US states have renewable energy mandates and eight have renewable-energy goals.

    Among Europe’s largest economies, 36% of Germany’s power consumed was produced from renewables in 2017 and that number was about 30% for the United Kingdom.5

    While the European Union (EU) has been a leader in renewable energy production in the first half of this decade, the United States and some emerging markets, including China and India, have been trying to catch up in the last few years and seem likely to exceed the EU over the next few years in renewable energy production.

    Concerns about air pollution have driven a push towards renewable energy in China. Its 13th Five-Year Plan targeted a 20% renewables goal by 2030, but there are some reports that China’s National Development and Reform Commission may be increasing the goal.

    India started this decade with almost no presence in renewables but is now on a path to 220 gigawatts (GW) of renewable capacity by 2022.6 Based on the auctions conducted and capacity added over the last two years, we do think this target is achievable.

    According to the International Energy Agency, three countries—China, the United States and India—will account for two-thirds of global renewable expansion to 2022.7

    Sustainable Living

    The third driver for renewables is the social push for sustainable living. My two children are just 8 and 6, and they actually forbid me from eating sushi with disposable wooden chopsticks. There is so much emphasis on sustainable development from future voters (including kindergarteners!) that this trend seems unlikely to slow down. Combine this with lower costs and regulatory support, and you have long-term momentum.

    Tapping Potential Investment Opportunities

    Newton’s third law states that for every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction. So, as renewables gain popularity, traditional producers that generate power from coal and nuclear—especially the merchant power producers in the United States and Europe—have suffered. As investors, we have largely avoided those power producers.

    On the other hand, as renewable power prices decline, the cost benefits are passed on to consumers in the form of lower utility bills. We don’t like investing in the renewables value chain where the business is commoditized, such as renewable power asset owners. We prefer to invest in developers—offshore wind for example—or energy providers who are the beneficiaries of lower prices.

    Another area of interest to us is gas pipelines and related infrastructure. Renewable energy is inherently unpredictable—the wind may not blow or the sun might not shine on a given day. So, typically it is combined with gas power, which can be switched on and off on a short notice of say 15 minutes when needed. Coal plants could take 2-3 days to start, and nuclear startup time is in months.

    As renewables grow, we expect gas power plants to complement renewables for reliability. Consequently, we also find investments in gas infrastructure throughout the world attractive as a complement to renewables. Overall, we see more potential opportunities in this space and are excited about what the future may hold.

    ENDNOTES

    1. Sources: NextEra Energy, US Department of Energy, IHS Markit. Compound annual rate.

    2. There is no assurance that any estimate, forecast or projection will be realised.

    3. Source: California Energy Commission, as of August 2018.

    4. Source: New York state, Reforming the Energy Vision.

    5. Source: European Commission, 2017 data.

    6. Source: Government of India, Ministry of New and Renewable Energy. There is no assurance that any estimate, forecast or projection will be realised.

    7. Source: International Energy Agency, “Renewables 2017.”