]> Press Releases--Closed-End Funds, Harvard University, "TCH", TDH and TAM Settle Lawsuit
tagline

Harvard University, Templeton China World Fund, Inc.,Templeton Dragon Fund, Inc., and Templeton Asset Management LTD. Settle Lawsuit

From: Franklin Templeton Investments
Contact: Lisa Gallegos
Telephone:(650) 312-3395
Telephone: Contact:
(617) 523-4400 Steven Alperin, Harvard Management



HARVARD UNIVERSITY, TEMPLETON CHINA WORLD FUND, INC.,
TEMPLETON DRAGON FUND, INC. AND
TEMPLETON ASSET MANAGEMENT LTD.
SETTLE LAWSUIT

 

HARVARD UNIVERSITY WITHDRAWS
ITS TEMPLETON CHINA WORLD SHAREHOLDER PROPOSALS
AND SUPPORTS TEMPLETON CHINA WORLD’S
OPEN-ENDING PROPOSAL WITH AN IN-KIND DISTRIBUTION FEATURE

 

HARVARD UNIVERSITY WITHDRAWS
ITS TEMPLETON DRAGON SHAREHOLDER PROPOSALS;
TEMPLETON DRAGON TO MAKE CASH TENDER OFFER FOR
15% OF ITS OUTSTANDING SHARES AT 92.5% OF NET ASSET VALUE PER SHARE

 

TEMPLETON DRAGON
TO SEEK AUTHORITY TO MAKE IN-KIND TENDER OFFERS

 

Fort Lauderdale, Florida and Boston, Massachusetts, March 20, 2003 – Templeton China World Fund, Inc. (NYSE: TCH), a closed-end management investment company (“China World”), Templeton Dragon Fund, Inc. (NYSE: TDF), a closed-end management investment company (“Dragon”), Templeton Asset Management Ltd., the investment advisor to each of the funds (“Templeton”), and President and Fellows of Harvard College (“Harvard University”) announced today that they had reached agreements that will result in, among other things, the dismissal of their litigation claims against each other and the withdrawal of Harvard University’s shareholder proposals for the funds’ upcoming annual meetings.  Also, Harvard will now support the Board’s proposal to open-end China World with an in-kind distribution feature, and Dragon will make a tender offer to be commenced on or prior to April 30, 2003, and may, pursuant to its settlement with Harvard, make additional tender offers in the future.

DISMISSAL OF LAWSUIT

The three settlement agreements announced today (between China World and Harvard, Dragon and Harvard, and Templeton and Harvard, respectively) will result in the dismissal without prejudice of the lawsuit originally brought in January 2003 by China World, Dragon and Templeton in the United States District Court for the District of Maryland, Northern Division, against Harvard University, Harvard Management Company, Inc., which is an investment advisor to Harvard University, and Steven Alperin, an officer of Harvard Management (collectively, “Harvard”), as well as the dismissal without prejudice of the counterclaims brought by Harvard against the funds, their respective directors and Templeton.  The parties have also entered into covenants not to sue each other with respect to the claims that were made or could have been made in the litigation absent a breach of the settlement agreements. 

END OF PROXY CONTEST

As part of the settlements, Harvard has agreed to withdraw all of its shareholder proposals for the respective upcoming 2003 Annual Meetings of Shareholders of China World and Dragon.  Harvard also will not solicit proxies from shareholders for the China World 2003 Annual Meeting and will not vote any proxies previously received.

CONVERSION OF CHINA WORLD TO AN OPEN-END FUND

Harvard announced that it intends to support the Board of Directors’ proposal at the 2003 Annual Meeting calling for the open-ending of China World, with an in-kind distribution feature described below.

If shareholders approve the open-ending proposal, the in-kind distribution feature will provide the fund the option of meeting large redemption requests through a pro rata, in-kind distribution of its portfolio investments by making an election pursuant to Rule 18f-1 under the Investment Company Act of 1940 and adopting related procedures.  This will allow the fund to minimize the potential adverse impact of large redemption requests on the fund’s net asset value per share.  Small redemption requests (generally in amounts less than $250,000 in any ninety-day period) will be paid in cash by the fund.

Harvard also announced that, if and when China World open-ends, Harvard will redeem all of its shares of the fund within 30 days after conversion, and that under the settlement it will take its redemption proceeds through a pro rata, in-kind distribution of portfolio investments.  As a result, the fund will avoid having to sell significant portfolio assets to raise cash to meet Harvard’s redemption request – thus limiting the potential adverse effect on the fund’s net asset value per share.

China World announced that if conversion to an open-end fund is approved by shareholders, the open-end fund would assess a redemption fee, not in excess of two percent, on all redemptions or exchanges of shares made within six months following the effective date of the conversion except on any redemptions of shares purchased after the conversion.

Representatives of Harvard and China World also have agreed to discuss, prior to conversion, steps China World might take to minimize any adverse effect on the net asset value per share of the fund resulting from a need to sell portfolio securities of the fund to raise cash to satisfy redemption requests.

DRAGON TENDER OFFERS

Dragon announced that as part of its settlement with Harvard, it has agreed to take the following actions:

·        April 2003 cash tender offer – The Board of Directors of Dragon approved the making of a cash tender offer to be commenced on or prior to April 30, 2003, for 15% of the fund’s outstanding shares at 92.5% of net asset value per share as of the date the offer expires.  Previously, the Board of Directors had approved an April 2003 cash tender offer for not less than 10% of the fund’s outstanding shares at not less than 90% of net asset value per share.

·        In-kind tender offers – Dragon also will apply to the Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”) for an exemption allowing the fund to make occasional, non-periodic tender offers, each for up to 20% of Dragon’s outstanding shares at a price equal to 95% of net asset value per share as of the date the offer expires, to be paid entirely in kind through a pro rata distribution of marketable portfolio securities.  The fund will not apply, however, for interval fund status.  Subject to certain conditions, the settlement requires the fund to commence such an in-kind tender offer for 20% of the fund’s shares within three months after obtaining the SEC exemption.  Dragon may also be required under the settlement to conduct, on substantially identical terms, up to two additional in-kind tender offers under certain circumstances.  There is no assurance that the SEC will grant the exemption, nor is it possible to predict the date when an exemption might be granted.

·        Additional cash tender offers – If the SEC does not grant the exemption for in-kind tender offers by May 26, 2004, the settlement provides that Dragon may, but is not obligated to, conduct an additional cash tender offer, and possibly later follow-on cash tender offers, each for 15% of the fund’s outstanding shares at a price of 92.5% of net asset value per share as of the date the offer expires.  Under certain circumstances, if Dragon does not conduct these tender offers, Harvard will be relieved of its obligation to refrain from making shareholder proposals and taking other actions with respect to the fund, as described below.

Harvard announced that it intends to tender all of the shares it then owns into each tender offer described above that is commenced.

The Dragon settlement agreement provides that Dragon will not be obligated to commence in-kind tender offers or additional cash tender offers under certain circumstances or conditions.  These relate to, among other things, the number of shares tendered by shareholders into preceding tender offers as well as the beneficial ownership percentages of the fund’s shareholders.

STANDSTILL

As part of the three settlements, Harvard agreed not to submit any proposals for consideration by shareholders of China World or Dragon, or any other closed-end fund or similar investment vehicle managed by Templeton or its affiliates, or for consideration by shareholders of Franklin Resources, Inc. (NYSE: BEN), the parent company of Templeton, nor to encourage others to do so, for a period of four years.  Harvard also has agreed not at any time to acquire additional shares of China World, Dragon or any other closed-end fund or similar investment vehicle managed by Templeton or its affiliates.

* * * * *

 

The summaries of the settlements reached by Harvard and China World, Harvard and Dragon, and Harvard and Templeton included in this press release are qualified in their entirety by reference to the full text of the three separate settlement agreements.  Copies of the settlement agreements will be filed by China World and Dragon with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission and will be available for free at the SEC’s website, www.sec.gov.  The parties have agreed not to make public statements (including to the media) regarding the settlements.

* * * * *

 

In connection with their 2003 annual meetings of shareholders, China World and Dragon intend to file relevant materials with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”), including their respective proxy statements.  Because those documents contain important information, shareholders of China World and Dragon are urged to read them when they become available.  When filed with the SEC, they will be available for free at the SEC’s website, www.sec.gov.  Shareholders also can obtain copies of these documents, when available, for free by calling China World or Dragon at 1-800-342-5236.

China World, its directors and executive officers and certain other persons may be deemed to be participants in China World’s solicitation of proxies from its shareholders in connection with its 2003 annual meeting of shareholders.  Dragon, its directors and executive officers and certain other persons may be deemed to be participants in Dragon’s solicitation of proxies from its shareholders in connection with its 2003 annual meeting of shareholders.  Information about their respective directors is set forth in the proxy statement for China World’s 2002 annual meeting of shareholders and for Dragon’s 2002 annual meeting of shareholders, respectively.  Participants in China World’s and Dragon’s respective solicitations may also be deemed to include the following executive officers or other persons whose interests in China World or Dragon may not be described in their respective proxy statements for China World’s and Dragon’s 2002 annual meetings: Mark Mobius (President and C.E.O. - Investment Management); Jimmy D. Gambill (Senior Vice President and C.E.O. - Finance and Administration); Charles B. Johnson (Vice President); Rupert H. Johnson, Jr. (Vice President); Harmon E. Burns (Vice President); Martin L. Flanagan (Vice President); Jeffrey A. Everett (Vice President); Gregory E. Johnson (President, Franklin Resources, Inc.); John R. Kay (Vice President); Murray L. Simpson (Vice President and Asst. Secretary); David P. Goss (Vice President and Asst. Secretary); Barbara J. Green (Vice President and Secretary); Michael O. Magdol (Vice President - AML Compliance); Bruce S. Rosenberg (Treasurer and Chief Financial Officer); and Holly Gibson Brady (Director of Corporate Communications - Franklin Resources, Inc.).

As of the date of this communication, none of the foregoing participants individually, or as a group, beneficially owns in excess of 1% of China World’s common stock or 1% of Dragon’s common stock.  Except as disclosed above, to the knowledge of China World and Dragon, none of their respective directors or executive officers has any interest, direct or indirect, by security holdings or otherwise, in China World or Dragon.

Shareholders of China World or Dragon may obtain additional information regarding the interests of the participants by reading the proxy statements of China World and Dragon when they become available.

____________

 

Dragon has not commenced any tender offer referred to in this communication.  Upon commencement of any such offer, Dragon will file with the SEC a Schedule TO and related exhibits, including the offer to purchase, letter of transmittal and other related documents.  Dragon shareholders are strongly encouraged to read these documents when they become available because they will contain important information about any offer.  When filed with the SEC, the Schedule TO and related exhibits will be available without charge at the SEC’s website at www.sec.gov.  Any offer to purchase and related letter of transmittal, when available, will be delivered without charge to all of Dragon’s shareholders.  Dragon shareholders may also obtain copies of these documents without charge by calling Dragon at 1-800-342-5236.

This communication is not an offer to purchase or the solicitation of an offer to sell shares of Dragon.  Any tender offer will be made only by an offer to purchase and the related letter of transmittal.  Neither the offer to purchase shares will be made to, nor will tenders pursuant to the offer to purchase be accepted from or on behalf of, holders of shares in any jurisdiction in which making or accepting the offer to purchase would violate that jurisdiction’s laws.