CONTRIBUTORS
Jacquelyn Reardon
Head of US Marketing
Franklin Templeton
To find and retain talent, employers continue to broaden their benefits programs. But employers’ offerings may not be in sync with what workers want.
Franklin Templeton’s 2024 “Voice of the American Workplace” survey found most workers are seeking more financial benefits. Being financially independent is a leading goal and financial benefits, such as an increase in salary or larger 401(k) match, are easily quantified.
At the same time, many employers focus on offering improved health benefits and financial wellness programs. While health care is an important consideration, employees don’t always understand the value of some benefits, resulting in an underutilization of programs. This could also impact their retirement planning and financial security.
The VOTAW survey found 70% of employer plan sponsors have increased the number and quality of their benefits in recent years. At the same time, 72% of employees reported some type of challenge in understanding the offerings. For example, responding to growing demand, 49% of employers introduced financial wellness programs, but only 28% of employees said they took advantage of them.
To achieve the most participation and deliver valued benefits, employers want to know what workers are seeking, and how best to communicate the offerings.
How employees choose benefits may offer insights
Many employers surveyed (85%) said employees have increasingly asked about personalized benefits. The data suggest more choice and flexibility could boost engagement and may influence employee decision-making about their jobs.
In addition, 63% of employers noted that voluntary benefits have become increasingly popular among their workforce.
Work-life balance gains traction
The personalization of benefits is a growing trend. It emerged in response to changes in the healthcare system allowing for more options and the changing workplace, which is providing more hybrid and remote work flexibility.
Work-life balance has been a growing focus of employees and employers, particularly since the COVID-19 pandemic. Most employers surveyed (87%) said: “Hybrid or remote work supports employee well-being, reducing stress related to commuting and enabling a healthier work-life balance,” with 85% admitting that it’s also an effective recruiting and retention tool.
In the area of healthcare, many companies offer a choice in plans. Today’s workers may find an array of health plans with varying degrees of coverage and deductibles. Some plans, such as high-deductible health plans, also allow participants to save in health savings accounts (HSAs), which offer multiple tax advantages and may support long-term financial goals.
Workers are concerned about finances
Workers’ concerns are largely related to finances, including income, retirement savings and healthcare costs. Within retirement savings benefits, workers want more choices and personalization of their 401(k) plans. Nearly two-thirds (59%) are worried about running out of money in retirement and 55% plan to do some work in retirement.
According to our survey, workers want to save, but they want to have a plan that suits their individual financial goals.
American Workers’ top concerns are all financially related, including income, retirement savings and healthcare costs
Which of the following concerns you the most? Please select up to three responses. (n=2,001 total) | How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements? (n=2,001 total | Top 2=Strongly/somewhat disagree). The Voice of the American Employer Survey was conducted by The Harris Poll on behalf of Franklin Templeton from November 6 to November 17, 2023. All 1,000 US respondents are classified as employers with over 100 employees. The Voice of the American Worker Survey was conducted November 9 to November 21, 2023, among 2,001 employed US adults, with some form of retirement savings.
Workplace savings offer opportunity for personalization
Workplace retirement savings plans offer opportunities to present workers with the flexibility to customize their savings to meet multiple goals.
American workers call for more personalized offerings, both in their 401(k) and overall benefit packages
How much do you agree or disagree with the following statements? (n=2,001 total | Top 2=Strongly/somewhat disagree) The Voice of the American Employer Survey was conducted by The Harris Poll on behalf of Franklin Templeton from November 6 to November 17, 2023. All 1,000 US respondents are classified as employers with over 100 employees. The Voice of the American Worker Survey was conducted November 9 to November 21, 2023, among 2,001 employed US adults, with some form of retirement savings.
The survey found 84% would be interested in a more personalized 401(k) investment option such as “a personalized portfolio, using factors such as age and income tailored to my unique financial situation.”
Also, 82% of workers surveyed said they would like to see customized benefits to meet their individual needs including financial and work-life balance goals.
Target-date strategies, a common default option in most 401(k) plans, have grown in popularity as a one-stop solution for retirement savers. The next generation of this strategy also focuses on greater personalization. A growing number of employers are considering more tailored investment strategies that are customized for a participant’s income, time horizon and individual savings goals within defined contribution plans.
Workers also recognize the value of the employer match in a 401(k) plan and 42% said they would like to see a larger match.
How the employer match is distributed is another area that is changing
The SECURE 2.0 legislation allows employers to use a company match to help participants as they make student loan payments. In fact, many workers (84%) surveyed said they are interested in student loan repayment assistance.
Today, student debt in the United States totals more than $1.7 trillion,1 and it is easy to understand how debt can be an obstacle to saving. Several studies found that workers with student loan debt on average contribute less to their workplace retirement plans compared with workers without debt. In our study, 47% of Millennial workers said, “Student loan debt is holding me back from significant financial milestones like buying a home or saving for retirement.”
Student loan assistance may help attract workers as well as support their savings goals.
Additional 401(k) options
Other policy changes allow employers to include a Roth option within their 401(k) plans, enabling participants to diversify their investments from a tax perspective. Some plan designs also help workers accumulate emergency savings.
Boosting engagement
The evolution of the 529 college savings plan is another example of how increased flexibility can engage more individuals. Originally designed to help families save for college, recent policy changes have expanded the use of 529 plans. In addition, 529 plans may be used for K-12 education tuition, qualified apprenticeship programs, funding of ABLE Accounts for people with disabilities, and student loan payment assistance. As of 2024, unused 529 assets may also be rolled over into a Roth IRA (within limits).
Our VOTAW study found as awareness of 529 plans grows, two-thirds of workers surveyed said they would be inclined to open an account knowing it can be used for more than college expenses.
New 529 account openings have grown steadily, reaching 15.9 million in 2022 from 10 million in 2009. Assets have also grown to $412.5 billion in 2022 from $133 billion in 2009, according to the College Savings Plans Network.2
Holistic approach to benefits
In general, workers want to see more choice in benefits that can be customized to meet their financial or work-life goals. With recent policy changes, there are a growing number of opportunities to create more choices and personalization in 401(k) plans. This valued retirement savings option may be able to help participants meet many of their goals.
The survey also found workers are focused on benefits that support financial independence. Consider the interest in offerings that will take them into retirement.
From paid time off payouts to long-term insurance, post-retirement benefits spark interest among American workers
Which of the following post-retirement benefits would you be most interested in, if your employer offered them?
Which of the following post-retirement benefits would you be most interested in, if your employer offered them? (n=2,001 total Top 2=Strongly/somewhat interested) | Q402_norm: Please select one statement from each pair below. - NORMALIZED (n=2,001 total) The Voice of the American Employer Survey was conducted by The Harris Poll on behalf of Franklin Templeton from November 6 to November 17, 2023. All 1,000 US respondents are classified as employers with over 100 employees. The Voice of the American Worker Survey was conducted November 9 to November 21, 2023, among 2,001 employed US adults, with some form of retirement savings.
Looking ahead to retirement, individuals said paid time off payouts, retirement health insurance, life and long-term care insurance were benefits they would be interested in if offered by their employer.
Endnotes
- Source: Education Data Initiative, data as of 2023.
- Source: College Savings Plans Network, data as of 2022.
For additional information, please contact the Franklin Templeton Retirement Sales Department at (800) 530-2432.
The Voice of the American Employer Survey was conducted by The Harris Poll on behalf of Franklin Templeton from November 6th to November 17th, 2023. All 1,000 respondents, based in the United States, are classified as employers, defined as having at least some influence over company benefits and/or hiring at organizations with over 100 employees. Respondents represent a mix of industries, company size, role, age, and race.
This presentation also references a qualitative study conducted by The Harris Poll on behalf of Franklin Templeton from August 15th to August 25th, 2023, among 15 American employers. All interviewees were full-time employees working in human resources, who have influence over employee benefits, and included those with titles such as HR Manager, HR Director or HR Vice President, among others.
This was a blind study, as Franklin Templeton was not mentioned in order to avoid bias.
The Voice of the American Worker Survey was conducted by The Harris Poll on behalf of Franklin Templeton from November 9th to November 21st, 2023, among 2,001 employed US adults. All respondents had some form of retirement savings. This online survey is not based on a probability sample and therefore no estimate of theoretical sampling error can be calculated. Findings from 2020 reference a study of a similar nature that was conducted by The Harris Poll on behalf of Franklin Templeton from October 16 to 28, 2020, among 1,007 employed US adults, study from 2021 also references a similar survey conducted among 1,005 employed adults from October 28th to November 15th, and a study from 2022 also references a similar survey conducted among 1,000 employed adults from October 17th to October 27th.
Franklin Templeton is not affiliated with The Harris Poll, Harris Insights & Analytics, a Stagwell LLC Company.